Could there be a yardstick for Greed? Who does not want to make money? Everyone knows risk and rate of returns are directly proportional! Having said that why to legislate some risky investments as illegal, if the individual is willing to risk!
Take for example, Ponzi schemes. Heard of Sharda Ponzi scheme that made Mamta’s TMC to hit the limelight for wrong reasons!
A typical Ponzi scheme, involves paying off early investors with proceeds from later investors. Many outside the financial circles may not know, it is named after Charles Ponzi, who was born in Lugo, Italy, on March 3, 1882. In 1920, Ponzi organized a company called Securities Exchange Co. in which he sold stock (promissory notes) advertising 50% interest after 90 days. Ponzi used funds obtained from new investors to pay off old investors. His scheme ran for over a year before it collapsed, costing his “investors” $20 million. Ponzi spent the last years of his life in poverty and passed away in 1941.
While this type of fraudulent investment scheme was not invented by Ponzi, it became so identified with him that it now is referred to as a “Ponzi scheme“.
But it is Bernie Madoff, who is famous for operating probably the largest Ponzi scheme in history. Madoff’s Ponzi scheme was operated through the wealth management portion of his business. It was a classic – and, in fact, frighteningly simple – Ponzi scheme. Madoff attracted investors by promising them extraordinarily high returns on their investments. However, when investors handed over the money, Madoff just deposited it into his personal bank account at Chase Manhattan Bank. He paid “returns” to earlier investors using the money obtained from later investors. Clients’ trading statements, showing their alleged profits, were complete fabrications.
It’s estimated that Madoff’s fraud extended for more than 20 years and ran to over $50 billion. Madoff was arrested in 2008 and eventually sentenced to 150 years in prison. So people haven’t learnt from their experience and law makers couldn’t detect a scam ‘timely’!
Now a days you hear of scandalous Ponzi schemes running in thousands of crores every year without a break!
There is another form of financial fraud called pyramid scheme. Ponzi schemes simply require a cash investment to earn returns, while Pyramid schemes, on the other hand, need you to pay a fee and/or purchase products and services in order to participate and earn income.
Burn Lounge scam for example, is an online music store that lured persons who paid for the right to sell music, while earning awards for recruiting other individuals into the business. The bonuses were not in any way tied to sales of merchandise. Between 2005 and 2007, the company is said to have conned 50000 people. $17 million was fined.
In 2008, Nine women have been found guilty of running a £21m get-rich-quick scheme, fleecing at least 10,000 victims after luring them in with “champagne celebration nights” and encouraging them to “beg, borrow or steal” the £3,000 needed to invest in the scam. Give and Take is an English scheme in which a group of operators requested £3,000 as an entry fee and promised a £20,000 bonus for recruiting a certain amount of new members. The individuals were convicted and served jail terms.
While such pyramid schemes are illegal, multilevel marketing (MLM), that works on almost similar principles, is legal!
If you join an MLM program, the company may refer to you as an independent “distributor,” “participant,” or “contractor.” Most MLMs say you can make money two ways: by selling the MLM’s products yourself to “retail” customers who are not involved in the MLM; by recruiting new distributors and earning commissions based on what they buy and their sales to retail customers. Your recruits, the people they recruit, and so on, become your sales network, or “downline.” MLM is not a pyramid scheme, it will pay you based on your sales to retail customers, even if you don’t recruit new distributors. Do you recall the popular ‘Tupperware’?
Are you clear now? Where lies the line of demarcation between pyramid scam and genuine MLM network?
Finance is such a complex science, that only crooks can make quick money, legally, till a new law is passed to declare such schemes as ‘illegal’! By the way wizards vouch ‘Bit coins’ neither fall under ‘Ponzi’ nor ‘Pyramid’ and hence are not illegal (so far). But who knows, what the future holds?
So, if you want to take risks legally, you are not categorised under ‘Geedy’ – from investing in fixed deposits to share market ‘stocks’; But if you start a ponzi or pyramid, sooner or later you would be ‘booked’ depending upon how ‘connected’ you are!
Here comes the story of my personal greed- Sometime back, when I was fiddling with my daughter’s mobile in Singapore, where I went for holidaying, a message popped up ‘simple questions – if you answer correctly you would get a free IPhone – conditions apply’! I was lured; I didn’t notice each SMS reply cost 1$. I started around 6 in the morning when everyone was busy organising to go to work. Each correct answer came with a response, ‘congrats – few more questions – the phone is yours’; around 830, I was fed up and closed the session! My daughter got a bill for an unexplained entry of 210$ (it was post paid) that month! Puzzled, she asked me, what did I do with her mobile? I couldn’t recall anything immediately. But later I mumbled her the episode with guilty. Obviously this being a case of cheating, she took up with authorities. They refused to accept our claim for the fraudulent phishing or scam as ‘the terms and conditions’ were accepted before entering the ‘quiz’! I never thought I could be taken for a ride so easily in Singapore! I felt guilty and my daughter paid the price for my greed!
That is Fraud in the new internet age! I paid for my greed to own an iPhone at no cost!
